I don’t remember a time when I didn’t know about the world
which the Pevensie children first enter through an old wardrobe. (If you’ve read the rest of the Narnia
Chronicles, you know that they and others also enter it through other portals
at other times.) In fact, I even
remember a time when the fact that Narnia is a fantasy world didn’t enter my
head. I was so young that it was
perfectly plausible to me that Narnia existed. I hadn’t yet developed that awful skepticism for which the Professor
chides Peter and Susan, that skepticism which assumes that things like Narnia
are impossible when really they are nothing of the sort.
When I was a child my dad read us the Narnia Chronicles and
the Little House books. He’d read one
series and then the other, and then go back to the first. It was a long time ago so I don’t remember
the specifics too well, but I think he read to us a few nights a week, one
chapter a night or two if we begged hard. My dad has a wonderful reading voice (so does Mom, actually) and we
would curl up around him to hear him read. It’s one of my favorite childhood memories.
(Tangent story: Mom tells about how, when she was pregnant
with Rosie, she spent a lot of time lying on the couch. I was a little over a year old at the
time. About every hour, which was how
often she would agree to read to me, I’d bring her a book and say “Book
me!” That was my way of saying I wanted
to be read to. Totally cute – if I do
say so myself, and shouldn’t.)
So anyway, Narnia seemed just as real to me as Laura and
Mary’s world (and frankly, not all that much more exciting – I couldn’t decide
if it would be scarier to face the white witch or the long winter, and more
thrilling to be crowned a queen or to ride in a buggy behind two wild horses
with a man who was in love with you). Even though Narnia is not “true” the way the Ingalls family’s story is,
there is much truth in it, and as a child I instinctively knew that.
I think it’s funny that Tolkien – whom I have to love because
he created my name, but would love even if my name were Mary – hated the Narnia
Chronicles even though Lewis was his dear friend. He called them Lewis’s “bully pulpit” and thought them horribly
obvious allegory. (If you’ve read The
Lord of the Rings, you know that Tolkien is no stranger to allegory, but he
was very scornful of strict allegory. His is much more subtle.)
I must admit that from a scholarly standpoint, the
Chronicles are not Lewis’s best work, or even his best fiction. The
Space Trilogy is better; Till
We Have Faces is far better. The Chronicles are laced with gaps and inconsistencies. They’re sometimes preachy. And, although I hate to grant it to His
Grumpiness Mr. Tolkien, the allegory is often really, really obvious.
But you know what? I
love them in spite of it, or perhaps because of it. I love that Lewis, who had far more prestigious things to do,
took the time to pen these little stories, things that children can read and
understand. I love that they give young
people a connection to the kind of adventure that isn’t considered worthwhile
anymore. I love that they show the
value of honor and truth and goodness and loyalty and sacrifice. I will certainly read them to my own
children, probably over and over again. They’re some of the most valuable children’s literature out there, in my
opinion.
Naturally, I was thrilled to learn that they were coming out
with a movie of The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe. I’ve seen the dorky old cartoon, of course
(it actually gave me a phobia of wolves that lasted for several years) but
live-action is so much better, and it’s only in the past couple years that the
technology has gotten good enough for them to do this well. (I personally have always hated it when they
try to mix animation and live action – Disney’s Mary Poppins,
anyone?) Of course, there was a lot of
of opportunity for them to completely bastardize the story, like Jackson did to
some parts of The Lord of the Rings, although I try not to think about
that. But I had a good feeling about
the Narnia movie, especially after I saw the poster.
My sister Maggie reread The Lion, the Witch, and the
Wardrobe right before she saw the movie. She actually finished the book in the theater before the show. And she warned me not to do that; she said
that she thought the filmmakers did a pretty good job of capturing the themes
of the story even though they changed a few details, but that having just
finished the book she got very distracted comparing the details, and it impeded
her enjoyment of the film. I took her
advice and didn’t reread the book, even though I’d originally planned on it.
I’m glad I didn’t, because I loved the movie, and if
rereading the book before I saw it might have tainted my movie-seeing experience,
I’m glad I dodged that bullet.
After I mentioned
that I loved the movie, someone said she’d like to read my thoughts on it,
which is why you have this post in all its rambling. I’ve thought a lot on what to say about the movie. I could tell how I loved the actors they got
to play the children, that little Georgie Henley as Lucy pulled off some of the
best child acting I’ve ever seen. I
could talk about how stunning the film was visually, how the costuming was
lovely, how Aslan in body and voice was so much better than I imagined
him. I could tell how Bryan loved it
too, so much that we’ve seen it three times now at his suggestion. I could tell how I both laughed and cried,
at different parts of the movie each time, or how I can’t recall another movie
that filled my heart quite so much. That sounds silly, but darn it, I just loved this film.
If I could say something bad about The Lion, the Witch,
and the Wardrobe, that would definitely make my viewpoint seem more
balanced. But I’m not cut out to be a
critic. As much as I get into nuances
when arguing about ideas, I can’t do it with creative works. Novels, movies, paintings, music, poems – my
gut tells me that a thing is “good” or “bad” (with “really good” and “really
bad” also being options in extreme cases) and I don’t move past that. I also admit that my tastes are not that
sophisticated; I’ve loved some ridiculous things and hated some great things
and that will probably continue for my whole life. The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe happens to be a
thing that I love. Every other person
in the world could hate it and I’d still feel the way I do. I love it loyally: I’m thrilled that it has
beaten King Kong in earnings, even though I’ve never seen King Kong. Now that I love the Narnia movie, I won’t
betray it by liking its competitor. If
that’s not a nuanced position, oh well. I guess I’ve got enough nuance in my life right now.
I’d love to hear all your thoughts.